13 Comments
User's avatar
Michellepollino's avatar

Alice, I have not read any Phillip Roth and now want to, what would you recommend as my first Roth read?

Expand full comment
Alice Elliott Dark's avatar

Why not read Goodbye, Columbus? It is great. I got a lot of notes from people saying they reread it often. I also love The Human Stain, and American Pastoral...the big books he wrote in his sixties. There are many literary experiments as well, and some people loves this most. Reading a bit about his huge oeuvre may help you decide.

Expand full comment
Michellepollino's avatar

ok just bought Goodbye, Columbus and The Human Stain! Oh happy day!

Expand full comment
Nancy Harmon Jenkins's avatar

Great comments. I am in my third reading of Transit of Venus and what you say applies so accurately to Hazzard's writing style. It flows, even when it jumps from one decade to another, from one place to another. Thank you!

Expand full comment
Erica Lansdown's avatar

Wonderful lesson! Thank you, Alice.

Expand full comment
Elise's avatar

New word for me, profluence; it is a beaut. It also evoked the Susan Sontag line I have scribbled all over the place sometimes as a reminder, sometimes as a mantra, " Love words, agonize over sentences and pay attention to the world. Thanks, Al, I needed that.

Expand full comment
Alice Elliott Dark's avatar

Love that! Yes, same idea indeed.

Expand full comment
Rosemary Porto's avatar

Thanks, Alice. I’ll save your advice and reread it over and over until it’s attached to my writing DNA.

Expand full comment
Laura Spence-Ash's avatar

“The reader, who has experience of how the world turns, recognizes in the movement between sentences that are cognizant of forward motion that they are in a rushing river in a safe boat.”

Love this, Alice. Such a great reminder. 💕

Expand full comment
Pamela Redmond's avatar

Did Chat GPT write the second version?

Expand full comment
Alice Elliott Dark's avatar

I haven't tried Chat GPT yet. Am I missing out?

Expand full comment
Elise's avatar

I'll never know as I'm sure it's going to suck out my soul.

Expand full comment
Nancy Star's avatar

That is one of my favorite paragraphs of all time. I’ve often read it with a sense of awe. It’s so perfect it feels magical. Thank you for the deep dive info why it’s so good at casting a spell that draws (yanks?) the reader in . 💕

Expand full comment